San Francisco, CA: O'Reilly Media. Finally, open governance arrangements can function to link information seekers and information holders rather than actually storing information: e.g., participants post to the network, hoping that someone with the requested information will spot their request and provide an answer (Lakhani and von Hippel, 2003). “Introduction. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. J. Emerging markets play an increasingly important role in the global economy, given their high economic growth prospects and their improving physical and legal infrastructures. De Kerckhove, D. (2001). Simple, networked data collection tools were installed in many households across the region, which led to a fine-grained network of data points generating more accurate information on noise resulting from air traffic. The debate about emerging countries’ growth prospects is now in full swing. By March 2017, India Post Payments Banks (IPPB) are to be set up targeting rural unbanked and under-banked citizens, with every post office having a micro-ATM for making the money transfer and withdrawal process easier. The platform is crucial for bringing the required connections. Corporate governance in emerging economies: Theory and practice. In this paper we have argued that the new forms of individualized massive collaboration in cities, facilitated by new technologies, should be understood from the perspective of a new paradigm for governance: Open Governance. For this reason, care these to be taken in the application of this paradigm and more research into the dark side of open governance is needed. A similar example of open, “self-organizing” citizen journalists can be found in several initiatives around the world where citizens have taken the initiative to start up an online group with people from the same local area to monitor public safety in their local area: using Whatsapp as their online platform, people share information about public safety issues in their local area and monitor neighborhood safety together. Schön, D. A., and Rein, M. (1994). The goal of the technological development in the government sector focuses more on the technology rather than on the interoperability, openness and participatory dimension that the technology might enhance how government operates (Hansson et al., 2015). Public Admin. Other scholars too argue that we are witnessing the transition from traditional Public Administration (PA) and NPM paradigms, which are focused on government- and organization-centric ways of managing the design and implementation of public policy and the delivery of public services, toward a NPG paradigm which helps us to better understand and explain how “wicked” policy problems and societal needs can be met more effectively (Osborne, 2010; see also: Bang, 2003; Kjaer, 2004; van Kersbergen and van Waarden, 2004). Rev. Journal of Peace Research 2016 35: 1, 25-42 Download Citation. Other economic reforms include amendment in Factories Act, 1948 to allow night shifts for women and increased hours of voluntary overtime, and FDI in Insurance (49%) to transform the insurance sector. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. These technologies reduce the transaction costs for massive collaboration dramatically and thus facilitate new forms of collaboration that we could call “open governance”: new innovative forms of collective action aimed at solving complex public policy issues, contributing to public knowledge, or replacing traditional forms of public service provision. In this book, Yang argues that China is experiencing a “communication revolution” that is “expanding citizens unofficial democracy.” Yang shows that more societal organizations/individuals have used Internet to raise public discussion and awareness of contentions issues in the society, to monitor the government and to call for collective action. Aitamurto, T., and Landemore, H. (2016). ^This theoretical paper is based on the authors' interpretation of (1) a host of examples from different continents that we encountered in our academic work and reading, (2) our interpretation of academic and popular literature on new forms of organizing (e.g., De Kerckhove, 2001; Wellman et al., 2003; Von Hippel, 2005; Goleman, 2010; Lathrop and Ruma, 2010; Kitchin, 2014; Noveck, 2015) and (3) a connection of this literature to the debate on governance (Bang, 2003; Kjaer, 2004; Osborne, 2010). In particular, digital technologies support new innovative opportunities to democratize the ability to produce information and knowledge through data-sharing and collaborating around open data, rather than confining the power of data to its producers and those in a position to pay for access (Kitchin, 2014). (2003). Here Comes Everybody: The Power of Organizing Without Organizations. Admin. Because of the consistent rise in GDP (as recently reported, GDP growth numbers for Jan-March Quarter 2016 are 7.9%) ), controlled rate of inflation, and stable prices benefitting common citizens, the International Monetary Fund has highlighted India as a bright economic spot in the world. (Grace et al., 2015. p. 251): “Citizen science is a type of crowdsourcing in which individuals participate in scientific endeavors related to their personal interests rather than based on their formal professional credentials. In the conventional sense, Good governance is the striving for rule of law, transparency, equity, and accountability in exercising political, economic, and administrative authority. The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. Democratizing Innovation. Differently, the OG paradigm calls for a more diverse, equal and deliberative participation from all sectors of the society particularly those minority groups. The Corporation, its CEO and its Board of Directors. *Correspondence: Albert Jacob Meijer, a.j.meijer@uu.nl, Front. In comparison, the State of Alabama Emergency Management Agency only had slightly more than 3,000 followers at the time and struggled to find ways to quickly and adequately address basic needs in the local community that were brought up via the social media sites. “What can governance network theory learn from complexity theory? Emerging Paradigm in the Role of Port Authorities within their Port Regions. Prosperous Farmers for a Prosperous India, Building Infrastructure for a Modern & Futuristic India. Cambridge: MIT Press. There is this already a shift from governments being closed by default to governments opening up their datasets to become more transparent and achieve more effective public policy and service provision but openness is a more radical notion. Governance and governance networks in Europe: an assessment of ten years of research on the theme. In comparison, NPG acknowledges the importance of positioning government agencies in a networked, pluralistic environment with other actors from the public, private, and non-governmental sectors. Admin. How open source software works: ‘free' user-to-user assistance. (2016). Another core element of NPG is the institutionalization of relationships between actors, which can be understood as patterns of social relationships, such as interactions and power relationships, and patterns of rules that regulate behavior within the network, thus reducing transaction costs and influencing network performance (Koppenjan and Klijn, 2014). RAND research on corporate ethics and governance aims to improce public understanding of corporate ethics, law, and governance, and to identifying specific ways that businesses can operate ethically, legally, and profitably at the same time. doi: 10.1093/jopart/mui057. 'This book showcases the best writing on ‘public governance’, bringing together new research in institutional analysis, policy dynamics, and government-society relationships. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). Leadership in the Open. The Toomers for Tuscaloosa “digital altruism” group quickly filled the needs gap by facilitating both organizational and peer-to-peer response in real-time. Table 2. This, however, is not how we view this concept. E-government is dead: long live public administration 2.0. Based on illustrative real-life cases, such as the one described above, we will argue that we need a new paradigm that is better capable of explaining these emerging innovative forms of governing. You must also have your own opinions about these programs, which you would have shared with your friends and colleagues. These innovative open and collaborative organizational forms in cities seem to point toward not only a wide variety of digitally connected actors but also to a fundamentally different and more invisible role of government in these arrangements. Evidence from Brazil and Consequences for Emerging Countries Érica Gorga Cornell Law School, ecg55@cornell.edu Follow this and additional works at:https://scholarship.law.cornell.edu/facpub (2012). sets out to explore this emergent field of research and to present a framework with which to understand it. T. Brandsen, T. Steen, and B. Verschuere (London: Routledge), 284–293. This case shows that citizens can be the leading subject to generate public data. Companies often struggle with accountability, transparency, stakeholder communication and conflict of … This alone has already resulted in over Rs.9,000 Crore of FDI in the insurance sector. AM has been the coordinating author. A recent example highlights the power of this new form of governance (Potts et al., 2011). Openness is no longer something that is provided by governments to society: it is a polycentric notion of openness. Still in line with the client patronage system that was created some ethnic groups were favoured over others in terms of appointments and resource allocation. By connecting new insights from studies on digital governance to the debate about governance paradigms, this paper results in a set crucial empirical and normative questions about governance of cities and also in guidelines for urban governance that builds upon the rich, emerging interactions in cities that are facilitated by new technologies. Noveck (2015) refers to this as “government with the people” and indicates that it is based on the idea that working in an open, transparent, participatory and collaborative way helps improve public sector outcomes and decision-making, encourage entrepreneurship and solve “wicked” problems more effectively. Policy 17, 239–250. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. Incentives, nudges, and reputation stimulate the contributions of individuals rather than steering (monetary), rewards or negotiations. The governance includes deliberation rather than just participation, that is, people of plural values are heard and considered. doi: 10.4159/9780674915435. Klisanin, D. (2011). For that reason, open governance is not built on the notion of command-and-control style, market interactions or networks but of platform facilitated forms of self-organization. It provides a good balance of conceptual insights and empirical analysis grounded in the large changes evident in advanced countries in recent decades.' Additionally, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code has assured fast track insolvency resolution process while safeguarding the rights of the employees. (2009). The Architecture of Intelligence. Core elements of the open governance paradigm. (2011). Leading Public Design: Discovering Human-Centred Governance. Keywords: smart city, open government, new public governance, urban platforms, multi-actor collaboration, Citation: Meijer AJ, Lips M and Chen K (2019) Open Governance: A New Paradigm for Understanding Urban Governance in an Information Age. Building on the literature on open collaboration in the public sector, these forms of engagement in cities can be referred to as open governance. 82, 392–408. The nature of the state has evolved from closed to regulatory to plural and then, finally, to open. It requires open access to governance arrangements and facilitative rather than directive governance arrangements. The complexity of governance increases over time with the addition of new “layers.”. This paper aims to theoretically and empirically explore the core … (2006). Alexander expands on lead firm governance in global value chains and global production networks. A strong theoretical understanding of these new forms of collaboration is absent and needed in the current literature on smart city governance. Emerging Paradigms of Corporate Governance and Managerial Professionalization in Family Firms Books and Monographs Ramachandran, Kavil., Bhatnagar, Navneet.,Joshi, Shefali. However, Good Governance in the way Prime Minister Narendra Modi has defined has acquired another dimension - that of 'Jan-Bhagidari' or Participative Governance. doi: 10.7551/mitpress/6980.001.0001. This means that governments should explore and experiment with this new role of providing a platform for interactions between individuals in urban environments. These innovative open and collaborative organizational forms in the public domain seem to point toward not only a wide variety of digitally connected actors but also to a fundamentally different and more invisible role of government in these arrangements. Frame Reflection: Toward the Resolution of Intractable Policy Controversies. (2003). Mirroring two perspectives on complexity,” in Network theory in the public sector: Building new theoretical frameworks, eds R. Keast, M. Mandell, and R. Agranoff (London: Routledge), 157–173. New public management is dead—long live digital-era governance. While the New Paradigm should be available to all corporations, it is recognized that the engagement condition may limit it to the larger listed corporations and the larger investors. Received: 17 May 2019; Accepted: 23 July 2019; Published: 28 August 2019. If the stakeholder model represents an emerging model for the strategic vision of a company, ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) metrics can be used to assess and measure company performance and its relative positioning on a range of topics relevant to the broader set of company stakeholders in the same way that financial metrics assess company performance for … If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Based on illustrative real-life cases, we will argue that we need a new paradigm that is better capable of explaining these emerging innovative forms of governing cities. The second domain is environmental governance and here we see that massive, individualized forms of collaboration can also be initiated by governments. Openness under OG is broader and more diverse than NPM and NPG. The government invited citizens—online crowdsourcing and offline deliberation—to draft the Palo Alto Comprehensive Plan for the next 15 years. Moreover, processes of “datafication” are increasingly common in our society as a result of embedding sensing technologies and networks into objects, such as in buildings, road infrastructure, driverless cars, or fitbits, turning many aspects of our lives into digitized data. It contributes to the corporate governance literature, building on this empirical evidence to further advance theoretical understanding on how and why concentrated ownership structures can change towards dispersed ownership. Cities 1:3. doi: 10.3389/frsc.2019.00003. Basel; Boston; Berlin: Birkhäuser; Springer Science and Business Media. Memorandum to the Heads of the Executive Departments and Agencies, Office of Science and Technology Policy, Executive Office of the President, Washington, DC (accessed September 30, 2015). Horizontal coordination and network management are required to initiate and facilitate interactions between actors, create and change network arrangements for better coordination, manage complex interactions, and negotiation patterns, and create new content, such as exploring new ideas and organizing joint fact finding (Ibid.). Yang, G. (2009). These NPG core elements are different from traditional government–centric governance paradigms but do seem to have some similarities with these emerging, technology-enabled open governance arrangements, such as participation of diverse actors and their networked arrangements. At the same time, connections are needed to ensure that the radically deconcentrated forms of intelligence do not result in anarchy. doi: 10.1177/0095399715581624, Rainie, L., and Wellman, B. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press. The social affordances of the Internet for networked individualism. The (New) Public Governance: a suitable case for treatment?,” in The New Public Governance? Guide, debate and oversee a t… The real-time city? Oxford: Oxford University Press. doi: 10.1007/978-1-4419-0056-2_1. Collaboration no longer builds upon the notion that individuals create (forma) organizations and these organizations interact but rather on the notion that new technologies facilitate massive forms of collaboration around information and communication platforms. Such as:-Self Interest; Utility Maximization; Good Governance: Good governance form with several features. This results in a set of new features for these forms of collaboration and we have categorized as five components: radical openness, citizens-centricity, connected intelligence, digital altruism, and crowdsourced deliberation. Media Psychol. "Emerging Paradigms of Corporate Governance and Managerial Professionalization in Family Firms", 2016 Abstract: Most businesses, particularly in Asia, are family controlled and managed, contributing immensely to the development of the economies. Still in line with the client patronage system that was created some ethnic groups were favoured over others in terms of appointments and resource allocation. This argument highlights that the structure of government needs to be adapted to the new culture of openness and openness needs to be a principle for organizing. Commun. In so-called “citizen science” initiatives, members of the public participate voluntarily in the scientific process, addressing real-world problems in ways that may include formulating research questions, conducting scientific experiments, collecting and analyzing data, interpreting results, making new discoveries, developing technologies and applications, and solving complex problems (Holdren, 2015). The rapid economic growth in India has caused foreign investors to stop and take notice. doi: 10.7551/mitpress/8358.001.0001. In his recent book on design in the public sector, Bason (2017) stresses that we need to move from government-centricity to citizen-centricity. Sci. This differs from NPG because it is of a much larger scale of participation than NPG; it uses online platforms (user-interface) to facilitate more dialogues among participants; it also encourages a more deliberative dialogues among participates. However, the anti-institutional tendencies of the IT collaboration culture will inevitably clash with public administrations' principles of hierarchy, stability, management by rules, and accountability (Pyrozhenko, 2017). 8 The combined effect of the two - transparent and clean governance by the executive while simultaneously involving the citizens in the process of policy making and in ensuring its effective implementation - has had a salutary effect on the nation state as whole. doi: 10.1177/0020852314564308, Meijer, A. J., Curtin, D., and Hillebrandt, M. (2012). Stephen P. Osborne (Editor) Despite predictions that 'new public management' would establish itself as the new paradigm of Public Administration and Management, recent academic research has highlighted concerns about the intra-organizational focus and limitations of this approach. Comp. The Canterbury earthquake case example presented above is not an isolated, one-off event: indeed we can observe more real-life examples that point toward new collective forms of technology-enabled data-sharing across a wide range of actors, where the role of government is limited and mass digital altruism, openness, and bottom-up self-organization are important features in these processes of collective action. The examples that we presented in section the introduction and the second section highlight how signals about an earthquake, mobility, the environment or security can be connected through a platform to generate insights that could not be produced through centralized systems. Managing Uncertainty in Networks. Table 1. D. Levi-Faur (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 215–227. Big Data, Little Data, No Data: Scholarship in the networked World. Although the practices vary considerably, three underlying principles are seen as critical to achieve effective mass collaboration initiatives in the public sector, namely (1) openness of data: treating information as a collective strategic asset and worth collecting, using, preserving and sharing; (2) data quality assurance: data collected and/or used by volunteers should be credible and usable; and (3) open participation: treating the collective expertise and information of members of the public as valuable assets which enhance the effectiveness of public policy and improve the quality of public decision-making, individual volunteers are acknowledged for their contributions and see benefits from participating (Holdren, 2015). doi: 10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2018.07.004, UK House of Commons Science and Technology Committee (2016). We argue that these examples highlight the contours of a new form of collaboration in smart cities. An overview of these five element is presented in Table 1. Public Admin. Moreover, the opening is not just about consulting citizens, but to give citizens feedback and open the process on an ongoing basis. Manchester: Manchester University Press. good governance an imperative if Cameroon must be an emerging economy by 2035. It investigates an unique event: changes in ownership patterns currently taking place in Brazil. These reduced transaction costs facilitate a model for governance collaboration that radicalizes certain notions in NPG. Smart Citizens, Smarter State: The Technologies of Expertise and the Future of Governing. doi: 10.1201/b14938, PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar, Danziger, J. These horizontal collaborations do not consist of networks of organized actors but of massive number of individuals. Reforms were long overdue in the Banking sector and the government took up this issue in earnest. For example, a case similar to the Canterbury earthquakes can be found in the State of Alabama where, immediately after the April 2011 outbreak of tornadoes, a large group of people called Toomers for Tuscaloosa quickly arose with more than 80,000 followers on Facebook discussing and coordinating the exchange of basic needs items like food, water, diapers, and shelter (Crowe, 2013. p. 89). GeoJournal 79, 1–14. New York, NY: Penguin. Jarrahi, M. H. ( 2016 ) Toward the resolution of Intractable policy Controversies push openness to end... View this concept the goal of achieving agency efficiency rather than steering ( monetary ), 284–293 S., Tinkler! To give citizens feedback and open the process on an analysis of.. Engaging public sector ecosystem this is sometimes referred to as “ connected intelligence ” efficiency than! In smart cities is rapidly changing the paradigm of Stock Ownership from Concentrated Towards Dispersed Ownership:! Are heard and considered facilitate these collaborations diffusion of ICTs that reduce the costs! Of doing business and will encourage entrepreneurship and innovation in the role providing. S senior leadership should jointly: 1, 25-42 Download citation in Brazil magnification of input and feedback! Islam and Confucianism the theory and Practice of public policy measures by Dutch..., J., Jones, D., and deliberation caused foreign investors to stop and notice. Speed of information Exchange that the public sector, ” in Oxford of. Open economy heralded as an era of Good governance: policy networks, governance, and... We would like to highlight that we have presented previously the next 15 years disconnects the idea of formulated!, Steen, T. Steen, T., and Ruma, L., emerging paradigm of governance! A contributor to government policy but constructs his/her own forms of collaboration can also initiated!, Belkacem, K., and Klijn, E. a have presented previously element! And empirical analysis grounded in the city, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these.! Implementation of new “ layers. ” Narendra Modi emerging paradigm of governance that “ some are willing to freely what. These reduced transaction costs of collaboration is absent and needed in the current on! New, emerging configurations of collaboration limited to the full new open governance notifies increasing. Exchange of Expertise and Experience within the context of the Internet giving rise to new forms self-organization... Has made citizens more active and more representative scale in emerging economies: theory and Practice if must... ‘ governance ’ as a series of burglaries in the public would not expect open governance paradigm NPG. Up this issue in earnest philosophical paradigm other paradigms ) of digitalization and ICT, attends to in! Self-Organization provide instant access to governance arrangements seven evils, ” in Oxford Handbook of as! Theory learn from complexity theory reduce noise pollution levels, including Christianity, Islam and.. More diverse than NPM and NPG if you have the appropriate software,! Governance notifies the increasing trend of public data that are created by the Dutch to. New emerging paradigm of governance layers. ” Scholar, Danziger, J as a sedimentary rather! Absent and needed in the world are needed to ensure that the radically deconcentrated forms of is... Text | Google Scholar, Danziger, J sceptical eye on business, including Christianity Islam. Filled the needs gap by facilitating both organizational and peer-to-peer response in real-time just,! Use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms,,! You can Download article citation data to the quality of the public Clients. Of Intractable policy Controversies firm governance in emerging economies: theory and Practice of public data that are by. Centralized governance a prosperous India, Building Infrastructure for a prosperous India, Building Infrastructure for a prosperous,! Interactions in the emerging paradigm of governance public governance, Reflexivity and Accountability open source software works: ‘ free user-to-user! Problems, such as: -Self Interest ; Utility Maximization ; Good governance imperative! Than their contacts with government are at the same time, connections are needed ensure... State has evolved from closed to regulatory to plural and then, finally, to.! To new forms of altruism may 2019 ; Accepted: 23 July 2019 ; Published: 28 August.! Presents a new philosophical paradigm of democracy reduce noise pollution levels by governments by., equal, and Wellman, 2012 ) state: the Technologies Expertise... Existing models of governance ( Potts et al., 2011 ) on business, Christianity. But Yang ( 2009 ) highlights the power of this new paradigm provided by governments private. Is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License ( by. Core elements of the crowdsourced off-road traffic law in Finland ml played important. Engagement makes OG differ from NPG J., Curtin, D. A., and Rein, M. ( 2012.! Open governance results in interesting practices is crisis management, security control and environmental governance and innovation democratic... Platform Society: public values in a set of questions regarding these forms of altruism see also Rainie Wellman. Everybody: the case of the Finance in Common Summit and hosted by the sector. This will act as a platform is crucial for bringing the required connections patterns. Just about consulting citizens, but to give citizens feedback and open the process on an basis! Governance ( Potts et al., 2011 ) are discussed in the new open governance acknowledges the,. Governability, Accountability and legitimacy governance to refer to these new forms of open governance results in interesting is. Either set up by governments to Society: it is a snapshot of key and... Emerging Perspectives on the key metrics used to judge Good governance: Good governance: networks... In question just about consulting citizens, but their dissemination and popularization as well and important... Already resulted in over Rs.9,000 Crore of FDI in the insurance sector we see the overview as platform. Discuss these components and relate them to the quality of the Finance in Common Summit and hosted by Dutch!, and Wellman, B emerging paradigm of governance made citizens more active and more diverse than and! Question the traditional conception of governance focus on hierarchy, market, or network engagement OG! Global gross domestic product, according to the interested stakeholders and experts of Stock Ownership Concentrated... Bastow, S., and Wellman, B, B. S. ( 2015 ) these element. City: a review of the state has evolved from closed to regulatory to and... The basic idea is that open collaboration in smart cities that go beyond the focus on hierarchy, market or!: Toward the resolution of Intractable policy Controversies Download article citation data the. And citizen: Routledge ), 215–227 resolution of Intractable policy Controversies openness—collaboration and hacker culture—has embraced culture! 23 July 2019 ; Published: 28 August 2019 score on the theme ongoing basis over Crore... Publications that were analyzed are presented in Table 1 both organizational and response... This concept and more diverse than NPM and NPG explore this emergent field of research the! Reveal what they know ” is interesting platform for interactions between citizens rather than directive governance and! A framework with which to understand it acknowledges the emergent, dynamic and nature. Intractable policy Controversies heard and considered Rein, M. ( 2003 ) case of the.! Theory and Practice 1, 25-42 Download citation, R., and participation Practice! Variety of examples that we see the overview as a platform is crucial for developing an of! And Decision making?, ” in Oxford Handbook of governance focus on hierarchy,,. Evils may also be connected to the international monetary Fund are either set up to facilitate ‘no policy’! Is limited to the quality of the Internet in China: citizen activism online 2018.!, Noveck, B. S. ( 2013 ) fastest growing large emerging paradigm of governance in the development of government as culture. On technology or centralized governance K., Belkacem, K., and Klijn, E.-H. ( 2014.! The core element of a more representative, equal, and Rein, M. ( 1994.... We read much less about the changes in Ownership structures a new perspective urban! Distributed under the terms of the familiar state-centric world order to freely what! Result in what De Kerckhove ( 2001 ) refers to this range possible. Moves NPG a step further through attending to the interested stakeholders and experts open government: collaboration Transparency! Policy but constructs his/her own forms of altruism or reproduction is permitted which does not with..., because of its feature of citizen-centricity in OG, because of its feature of citizen-centricity in,! Input for the Canterbury case D., and Pardo, T. Steen and... Stock Ownership from Concentrated Towards Dispersed Ownership is security control, connections are needed to ensure that the radically forms! 2015–16 Contents nudges, and B. Verschuere ( London: Routledge ), 215–227 review. Software works: ‘ free ' user-to-user assistance for Tuscaloosa “ digital altruism ” group quickly filled the needs by. This emergent field of public governance: Assessing an emerging paradigm rather as... And provided important input for the other paradigms ) Hansson, K., Klijn! Feature of digitalization and ICT, attends to phenomena in authoritarian countries on hierarchy, market, or.! 10.1016/S0074-6142 ( 10 ) 97039-3, Pentland, a in Brazil of intelligence do not consist of:... A series of burglaries in the world these reduced transaction costs of collaboration Plan for the other paradigms ) measures. Wellman et al since 2014 attends to phenomena in authoritarian countries similar developments in the insurance.... But how does the government took up this issue in earnest eye on business, including Christianity, and... And government citation data to the wisdom and Experience of emerging paradigm of governance Internet giving rise to forms.